YALSA's Teens' Top Ten

[ewein2412]

I get challenged again and again: “Why is Code Name Verity considered young adult fiction? The characters are too old. The writing is too literary. The situation is too harsh.” And that is all true. Sometimes these challenges are polite, and made directly; sometimes I encounter them, more hurtfully, online. “Nothing happens in the first 200 pages, it’s so boring.” “There are too many technical details.” “I can’t imagine a teen reader engaging with this book.” “My whole freshman class has to read this and we all hate it.” Oh, man. Author nightmare, your book turned into a school assignment that everybody hates!

I have very little idea how many teens actually read and enjoy Code Name Verity. When I speak to school groups, they usually haven’t read it yet. When I speak at bookstores, the audience is almost always overwhelmingly composed of grown-ups. But every now and then I get a hint that there are target audience fans out there too. In Politics & Prose in Washington, DC, I met a 12-year-old girl who had read Code Name Verity five times (when she was eleven). She said it was her favorite book. She had forced it on her best friend, who had read it twice. I remind myself about these kids whenever I feel down. And also of the occasional amazing school visit like Heart of England, which read CNV for the Carnegie Shadowing scheme. And also of the occasional evangelistic readers my daughter (now 16) meets online. These are the opposite of the nightmare scenario.

I knew that Code Name Verity was one of the 28 titles in the running for the YALSA Teens Top Ten list for 2013, but I totally, totally did not expect it to make the final cut. Last night I was flabbergasted to learn that it came in as Number One.

Here's a congratulatory tweet I received from Jenn Calder which really encompasses what this means to me:

Code Name Verity's well-deserved #TTT win proves that teens are intelligent, discerning readers: http://t.co/qLPvSY9E47 @EWein2412 @yalsa

— Jenn Calder (@jenncalder) October 22, 2013

Okay? Okay! People! It doesn’t prove anything about CNV so much as it proves that teens are intelligent, discerning readers. The whole fabulous list does. I’d have been proud to be anywhere on it. Heck, I was proud to be one of the 28 nominees.

Here it is in full.

1. Code Name Verity by Elizabeth Wein (Disney/Hyperion)
2. The False Prince by Jennifer A. Nielsen (Scholastic/Scholastic Press)
3. Insurgent by Veronica Roth (Harper Collins/Katherine Tegen Books)
4. Pushing the Limits by Katie McGarry (Harlequin Teen)
5. Poison Princess by Kresley Cole (Simon & Schuster)
6. The Raven Boys by Maggie Stiefvater (Scholastic/Scholastic Press)
7. Crewel by Gennifer Albin (Macmillan/Farrar Straus Giroux)
8. Every Day by David Levithan (Random House/Alfred A. Knopf)
9. Kill Me Softly by Sarah Cross (Egmont)
10. Butter by Erin Jade Lange (Bloomsbury)

Thank you, YALSA teens. I am going to stop doubting myself now.

http://www.ala.org/yalsa/teens-top-ten

Comments

[rj-anderson.livejournal.com]

*outraged glare* EXCUSE ME WE ARE TRYING TO HAVE A CONVERSATION HERE.

(Ugh, I still can't believe the woman was THAT rude. Way to stomp all over the Canadian reputation for politeness, lady.)

[ewein2412]

don't worry, I didn't attribute it to her being canadian. more to my being a loud american, which reputation I was steadfastly upholding.

[rj-anderson.livejournal.com]

I don't believe you were any louder than I was! Ah well.

[3rdragon]

I haven't heard this story. I'm assuming it happened after I saw you last?

(Also, congrats! I should read some of those other books.)

[ewein2412]

rj_anderson and I were having dinner in a restaurant in Canada - the first time we'd met in person! And we were exchanging many writerly joys and woes, and we'd been to the Canadian Air Heritage museum and it had been a long day, and I was laughing at something. Loudly. And next to us was an older woman with a quite elderly companion, who was certainly old enough to be hard of hearing, and the younger of the two leaned across from her table and said something like, "Could you please keep it down. I know you're having a good time but it's making it difficult for us to hear each other."

I gave her a long steely LOOK before answering something like "I'm sorry," but I really, really WISH I'd had the presence of mind to jump up and introduce myself to the old woman and smile and say how much I understand because my grandmother is 97 and also a little hard of hearing, and how nice it is that they are having a meal out, and do they do this often? Because if I had smothered them with charm and graciousness they would have felt GUILTY instead of CRABBY. And everybody would have won. Instead we just ALL went away feeling crabby.

This kind of universal crabbiness happens far too often, I think - people need to break the chain!

[rj-anderson.livejournal.com]

something like, "Could you please keep it down. I know you're having a good time but it's making it difficult for us to hear each other."

Only without the "please" or the "I know you're having a good time", and in a very snappish tone. That was the part that took me aback: I've been out with plenty of loud, laughing people in my time and sometimes been asked if we could speak more quietly, but never in such a rude, abrupt way as that lady did!

However, if it hadn't happened, I suppose the afternoon wouldn't have been quite so memorable and we wouldn't have as much to chuckle about. :)

[ewein2412]

get out, we went to the Canadian Air Heritage museum and saw the Lancaster being wheeled into the hangar. It was memorable anyway.